Schwab: The buck stops with me

Melbourne FC has confirmed the resignation of chief executive Cameron Schwab after a disastrous start to the season

Melbourne CEO Cameron Schwab faces the media with club president Don McClardy after resigning his position at the Demons. Picture: Michael Klein Source: Herald Sun

Embattled Demons coach Mark Neeld talks to his players. Source: Getty Images

BESIEGED Melbourne chief executive Cameron Schwab has resigned.

Schwab confirmed at a press conference this afternoon that he had agreed to quit after being asked to step aside by club president Don McLardy.

Asked if he was a scapegoat, Schwab said: "I know how the system works."

McLardy said Schwab had divided the Demons fans and the club had to move on from a disastrous four years with Schwab in charge - despite the fact he was reappointed with a new three-year contract in August last year.

The Dees' shocking start to the season, coupled with the AFL's tanking investigation, has put Schwab under fierce pressure.

Melbourne has lost its opening two matches by a combined 227 points, including a 148-point drubbing by Essendon last Saturday night.

McLardy said the issue came to a head over the past two days.

"What has happened in the past two games is clearly not acceptable," he said.

"You were here in the weekend, you all saw it ... we cannot let that continue. We would be derelict in our duty if we did not address that in some way."

McLardy denied Schwab had taken the fall for the poor performance of coach Mark Neeld and the Melbourne playerss.

He said Schwab had done an excellent job off the field in returning the club to a strong financial position but ultimately was responsible for what happens on the field as well as off it. He also denied removing Schwab was purely to appease angry Demon supporters.

"We're all accountable. Our job as a board is to look at what's in the best interests of our footy club," McLardy said.

"We've got a divided supporter base, we've got a lot of issues with supporters looking at us and saying what is the direction we're heading, we have to offer them hope and change.

Why coach Mark Neeld should be nervous

"The business side is solid, clearly the football part is not acceptable and that is part of the role of the CEO.

"There are lots of issues surrounding Cameron and the last four years that we have to put behind us."

Schwab started at the Demons as a 17-year-old in 1981 and worked at Richmond and Fremantle before starting his current stint with the club in 2008.

He said he was "up for the fight" but respected McLardy's position when he was asked to fall on his sword.

"I know the difficulties the club faces now and ... I wasn't going to back away at all from where the club sits.

Jack Grimes and Nathan Jones after the match Picture: Harman Stephen Source: Herald Sun

"But I also understand that if you're in a position where you have to fight the sort of battles the club is fighting, you all have to be in it together.

"I knew straight away if there wasn't the basis we could fight together it was time for me to make the choice that I have made.

Schwab said he accepted some responsibility for the club's on-field failures.

"The losses that we've had, clearly there's no way you can assess that and explain it away.

"This club will bounce back, don't worry about that, this is a much better and a much stronger club than what it's representing itself as at this time.

"When the club has its day, which it will, there will be a lot of people who will be very proud - and I'll be one of them."

Melbourne CEO Cameron Schwab faces the media with club president Don McClardy after resigning his position at the Demons. Picture: Michael Klein Source: Herald Sun

Schwab said stepping aside would give the club "the opportunity to move forward."

"Ultimately, I recognise the on-field performance is an indirect situation from the role I play as CEO."

McLardy said coach Mark Neeld was not under pressure to keep his job, and he felt safe as president.

He said he would meet with the club's board and AFL boss Andrew Demetriou in the next 48 hours.

Schwab was sacked for 48 hours in 2011 but survived when the board instead sacked then coach Dean Bailey.

Despite his lengthy tenure in the game, Schwab has never been involved in a premiership.

Melbourne CEO Cameron Schwab faces the media with club president Don McClardy after resigning his position at the Demons this morning. April 9, 2013. Picture: Klein Michael Source: Herald Sun

SCHWAB FILE
CEO: 451 games
WINS: 164
WIN-LOSS RATIO: 36%
FINALS SERIES: 3
COACHES SACKED: 4 (Kevin Bartlett, Neil Balme, Chris Connolly, Dean Bailey)

REPLAY THE LIVE CHAT BELOW

On a mobile? Click HERE for a better chat experience
 

16.55 | 0 komentar | Read More

Stevie J could face Blues

Geelong star Steve Johnson is on the verge of returning from injury. Source: Getty Images

GEELONG forward Steve Johnson is a chance to return against Carlton on Saturday night, while Jared Rivers has been ruled out for up to three more weeks.

Johnson had minor surgery on his left knee on March 26, and Cats coach Chris Scott said today he could be back against the Blues at Etihad Stadium.

"He's some sort of chance. He'll be disappointed that I've rated him some sort of chance, he's very confident that he'll play, our medical staff think he's a chance but there's just more work that needs to be done before we can make a definitive judgement,'' Scott said.

"Steve has a bit of input but the medical staff has more, they're the ones that need to make that judgement.

"Only he knows how he feels so that's where he comes into the decision-making process and I'm clearly third in line when it comes to making that decision.

"In terms of his preparation to play AFL football through the pre-season, he's got a lot of work behind him and we're confident that if he's available and he comes into the team, that he'll be able to perform to a high level based on that preparation.''

Scott confirmed that Rivers who missed Sunday's comeback win over North Melbourne had a slight strain of the posterior cruciate ligament.

"The prognosis was anywhere between two and four weeks, so we're banking on three but if it is four it wouldn't surprise us,'' Scott said.

"He won't play until he's absolutely ready to play his best footy.''

Scott said young forward Daniel Menzel was a certainty to play his first game back in the VFL this week after undergoing his third knee reconstruction over summer.

16.55 | 0 komentar | Read More

Schwarz: Dees need more change

David Schwarz has forecast more change at the Dees. Picture: Fiona Hamilton Source: Herald Sun

MELBOURNE great David Schwarz has forecast more change than just the sacking of chief executive Cameron Schwab at his old club, following the Dees' disastrous start to 2013.

Schwarz highlighted Port Adelaide's undefeated opening to the season as proof of what rejuvenation could produce.

"There will be more changes. There has to be," Schwarz said on SEN.

Why Mark Neeld is under pressure

"You have to remember Cameron Schwab was a part of the recruitment of (coach) Mark Neeld,'' he said.

"He was one of four people involved in that recruiting process. He would be feeling responsibility.''

Last off-season the Power appointed a new president, new coach and invested heavily in youth at the national draft to plant the building blocks of its next era.

Schwab: The buck stops with me

Schwarz said Port Adelaide went through a similar predicament to the Dees last year before "coming out the other end".

"So, there might be light at the end of the tunnel."

Demons president Don McLardy asked Schwab to resign despite ensuring the club would make no rash changes on Sunday, just 12 hours after the record-breaking 148-point loss to Essendon.

He today gave similar support to Neeld, declaring: "Mark Neeld is not on notice.''

Schwab was re-signed on a three-year contract last year, while Neeld - 24 games into his coaching tenure - has a deal until the end of 2014.

16.55 | 0 komentar | Read More

Hawks lose Sewell for Pies clash

Hawthorn's Brad Sewell is out with a hamstring strain. Source: Getty Images

COLLINGWOOD star Scott Pendlebury will not have to contend with Brad Sewell in Sunday's blockbuster after the Hawthorn hardnut was ruled out with a hamstring strain.

The Hawks tonight revealed Sewell, who usually lines up on Pendlebury, would miss up to two weeks.

He tightened up during Sunday's impressive win against West Coast and was substituted out during the third quarter.

Hawks acting football manager Chris Fagan said Sewell underwent a scan, which showed "a bit of bleeding in the hamstring".

"Brad was able to jog lightly today, and depending on how quickly the injury site settles we expect him to resume playing within the next 1-2 weeks."

But the Hawks could be bolstered by the return of recruit Brian Lake after the veteran defender emerged unscathed from his VFL return on Sunday.

Hawthorn also regained captain Luke Hodge last week and enter the Collingwood showdown slight favourites.

The Hawks face Fremantle after the Pies, with Sewell hoping to return for that clash.

16.55 | 0 komentar | Read More

If you don't mind, umpire

A controversial free kick and 50m penalty has gifted Geelong another remarkable comeback victory at Etihad Stadium today.

Jimmy Bartel kicks the winning goal for Geelong. Picture: George Salpigtidis Source: Herald Sun

WE PICK the five biggest umpiring eyebrow-raisers of the weekend.

Umpiring is a tough job - getting tougher every year with more rule tweaks and interpretation changes - and most of the time the men in white/green/red do a great job. Sometimes, however, we need to examine some issues closer to get a clear explanation and help everyone's understanding of the game.

Each week we'll nominate five decisions that demand a second look. Then we'll take on board your views and any nominations we've missed, and get a verdict from AFL House.

Have your say on these decisions and let us know any we missed by leaving a comment below or sending a note on Twitter or Facebook

1. FOOTY LOGIES

In the spirit of last night's awards ceremony for Australia's TV industry, several players put in bids for their own acting awards on the weekend. The first nominations came on Friday night, with Shaun Grigg making sure the umpires didn't miss a late Lenny Hayes bump then Nick Dal Santo hitting the turf as if he'd been hit by a sniper in the top deck rather than copping a brush to the face from Shane Tuck.

But both efforts may have been topped yesterday by North Melbourne forward Lindsay Thomas, who won a crucial free for kicking in danger after Geelong ruckman Trent West tried a clumsy toe-poke late in the third quarter. Thomas, who was trying to pick up the ball, threw his hand back then fell to the ground, then drilled the goal to extend the Kangaroos' lead.

2. FIRRITO'S BRAIN FADE

The umpires were in focus again in a dramatic finish to that game, with Jimmy Bartel kicking the winning goal from a free kick and 50m penalty.

The free was clear-cut after Nathan Grima collapsed into Bartel's back about 30m out from the Cats' goal. Then veteran Michael Firrito made a bad situation a whole lot worse by picking up the ball and booting it as far away as he could.

Firrito says the crowd was "really loud" but the umpire was only a few metres away and the free could not have been in the Kangaroos' favour. Making the matter worse was the fact Firrito gave away a 50m penalty for exactly the same offence in Round 1.

Watch the video above and make up your own mind

Nathan Grima crashes into the back of Jimmy Bartel, giving away a free kick. Picture: George Salpigtidis Source: Herald Sun

3. TIGERS' FREE RUN

St Kilda's defence has enough issues at the moment without adding a lack of discipline - or unfriendly umpires, depending on your point of view - to the list.

Richmond won seven free kicks in its forward 50 on Friday night while the Saints received just one in their attacking arc.

Jack Riewoldt was the chief beneficiary, earning four frees while Jake King won three and Luke McGuane two.

Saints fans were particulary unhappy when Tyrone Vickery earned a shot at goal after Jason Blake was penalised for a high spoil - there didn't seem a lot in it but photographic evidence below shows the ump was on the money.

Sam Gilbert can consider himself more hard done-by after he was pinged for holding the ball early the match despite being buried under a pack of about eight players.

Jason Blake gives away a free kick for holding Ty Vickery. Picture: Wayne Ludbey Source: Herald Sun

4. BROWN PUSH A GREY AREA

It was the ultimate 50-50 situation - the game in the balance with just minutes remaining and a loose ball on the wing.

Carlton's Dennis Armfield got there first at the MCG yesterday but was pushed out of the way by Collingwood defender Nathan Brown.

Did Brown put his hands in Armfield's back? If he didn't, they were very close. Armfield hit the turf, the umpire waved play-on and the Pies swept forward. They scored a behind from that play but it was the Blues' last best chance to pinch the game.

Adelaide captain Nathan Van Berlo charged by match review panel after trying to handball and hitting his opponent's face instead.

5. ONE VIDEO HENDO LIKES

Adelaide's Ricky Henderson had his name in the papers today for the wrong reasons, but he scored a great long goal against the Lions on Saturday - helped by the video review system.

After Henderson swept down the wing and launched his long shot from 50m, the goal ump at the Gabba was in perfect position - in fact it was so good he was exactly where Brisbane's Tom Rockliff jumped in a desperate effort to touch the ball.

Rockliff did just that but also flattened the goal ump and the decision on whether the ball had crossed the line before he got a fist to it was left to the video ref. With the only available footage seemingly taken from the wing, it was impossible to know exactly where Rockliff made contact. It seems unlikely the ball was entirely over the line, but Hendo got the benefit of the doubt.

At least the goal ump escaped unscathed, unlike his colleague at Etihad Stadium earlier that day.

16.55 | 0 komentar | Read More

Crows furious over TV player flash

Adelaide star Patrick Dangerfield says broadcasters must respect players' privacy. Picture: Sarah Reed Source: Herald Sun

Forward Ricky Henderson returns to Adelaide following the Crows win in Brisbane. Picture: Sarah Reed Source: Herald Sun

Forward Ricky Henderson returns to Adelaide after being exposed by a changeroom camera. Picture: Sarah Reed Source: Herald Sun

UPDATE: STAR Crows midfielder Patrick Dangerfield has declared his disappointment at the AFL's official telecasters for embarrassing team-mate Ricky Henderson at the weekend.

Of Foxtel's decision to show Henderson as he opened his shorts in the changerooms at the Gabba on Saturday, Dangerfield said: "The broadcasters have a responsibility to respect the players' privacy. It's disappointing."

The Crows players will gather today to consider their response to Fox Footy not editing the Henderson moment from its coverage and Channel Seven's decision to lampoon Henderson during its Saturday night football telecasts.

The Adelaide Football Club at the same time will be seeking apologies from the telecasters and assurances the moment will not be repeated.

The broadcasting of the footage resulted in thousands of messages bombarding Henderson's Twitter account, increasing his embarrassment.

"Ricky was really stressed (on Saturday night)," said Adelaide football chief Phil Harper.

"He should have been joining his teammates celebrating a good win against the Lions; instead he was locked away in his room.

"We are quite angry that people chose to put the original footage in other forums, particularly social media.''

Rucci's Rip: A Showdown worth savouring

Henderson was captured on camera walking into the Adelaide rooms at half-time and opening his shorts out of concern for a groin injury.

It is unlikely Henderson will follow rugby league player Andrew Ettingshausen in legal action.

Ettingshausen was awarded $350,000 in damages - reduced to $100,000 on appeal - from a magazine that published a photograph of "ET" in the showers during the 1990 Kangaroos tour of Great Britain.

The REAL Showdown - Sanderson v Hinkley

Ettingshausen had the expectation of privacy in the team showers. But Henderson should have been aware of the cameras that have been placed in AFL team changerooms for more than 10 seasons.

"We thought everything filmed in the changerooms was shown on delay and the telecaster had the opportunity to drop images such as those of Henderson," Harper said.

"Ricky's quite distressed by it all. He plays footy - he is not worrying about cameras when he comes into the changerooms."

Beyond Fox Sport's error, Adelaide has taken exception to how Henderson was lampooned on Seven's Saturday night football coverage hosted by former VFL player Brian Taylor.

Match report - Crows beat the Lions

AFL Players' Association executive Ian Prendergast says his group will be questioning the telecasters.

"We'll follow up to find out why (the images were put to air)," said Prendergast.

"Cameras are in place in the changerooms on the basis player privacy will be respected."

A fatal motorcycle crash at Meningie, the debate over live changeroom cameras and the Reds out of the A-League finals

16.55 | 0 komentar | Read More

The Barometer: Round 3

Sean Dempster played out Friday night's match with a broken hand. Picture: Wayne Ludbey Source: Herald Sun

Dale Thomas tries to get around Chris Giampaolo during the VFL match between Collingwood and North Ballarat at Victoria Park Picture: Harman Stephen Source: Herald Sun

WHO'S hurt and who is in line for selection at your club?

ADELAIDE

INJURIES
Brodie Smith (collarbone) 1-2 weeks

ON THE BLOCK: Ian Callinan has struggled to make an impact inside the arc and should find his name bandied about at the selection table. Bernie Vince had an off day against the Lions but expect him to line up in Sunday's Showdown.

ON THE CUSP: Graham Johncock has been around long enough to know the importance of good timing. And the wily veteran delivered, kicking seven goals in the SANFL. Sam Kerridge was the standout for Sturt with 30 disposals, 10 tackles and eight clearances.

GILBERT GARDINER'S FORECAST: Scott Thompson stood up when the Crows needed a leader last Saturday night. The Lions had their rivals on the ropes for much of the second half with Rory Sloane and Patrick Dangerfield largely unsighted – until five minutes of matchwinning brilliance at the end. But Thompson was resolute, finishing with 31 possessions including eight inside-50s and seven clearances. The Crows will need much of the same to mow down their plucky Alberton rivals on Sunday. Sam Jacobs has the stoppages at his mercy while Tex Walker v Jay Schulz looms as a mouth-watering shootout. And wouldn't it be great if we saw these blokes going head-to-head: Dangerfield v Boak, Sloane v Hartlett and Thompson v Cornes.

BRISBANE

INJURIES
Simon Black (knee) 2 weeks
Michael Close (foot) 2 weeks
Brent Staker (knee) 3-4 weeks
Jesse O'Brien (adductor) 5-6 weeks
Stephen Wrigley (knee) season

ON THE BLOCK: Pre-season bolter Patrick Karnezis can't be happy with his output thus far. Did little in Round 1, and started as the substitute against Adelaide. Mooted as a midfield/forward with upside, Karnezis was in 23 per cent of all Nissan SuperCoach teams last week. Reckon a few might be pulling the trigger on the boy from Oakleigh.

ON THE CUSP: Ryan Harwood was best afield in the Lions' NEAFL win over GWS Giants. Todd Banfield got plenty of it while young gun Sam Docherty was solid out of the defence. Jordan Lisle and Marco Paparone bagged two goals apiece.

GILBERT GARDINER'S FORECAST: Tough 0-2 start for the NAB Cup premiers and it's not going to get any easier in the Q-Clash. Despite the Lions' 3-1 record against the Suns, only one of those wins has come at Metricon Stadium. Daniel Rich copped another pasting under a hard tag while Jonathan Brown has plenty of room for improvement.

COLLINGWOOD

INJURIES
Clinton Young (hamstring) TBC
Darren Jolly (ribs) TBC
Dayne Beams (quad) 1 week
Luke Ball (knee) 1-2 weeks
Brodie Grundy (back) 3-5 weeks
Michael Hartley (shoulder) 5 weeks
Lachlan Keefe (knee) 5-7 weeks
Tim Broomhead (glandular fever) 8 weeks

ON THE BLOCK: Darren Jolly looks set to miss after cracking a rib in the first quarter yesterday. The Pies' big man was taken to hospital in agony, but apart from that Collingwood was full of dazzling performers. But with premiership players ready to walk back into the side, Paul Seedsman, Brent Macaffer and perhaps veteran Ben Johnson could be getting nervous across the next few weeks.

ON THE CUSP: The Pies had Dale Thomas, Alex Fasolo, Alan Didak and Clinton Young play VFL on Saturday. Young injured his hamstring but the early word is it won't be too bad, while Thomas looks certain to face the Hawks this week. Ben Hudson, already promoted to the senior list, should replace Jolly if he doesn't come up this week.

SAM LANDSBERGER'S FORECAST: The Pies are 2-0 with a suddenly thinning injury list. They've regained Shaw, have Didak, Fasolo and Thomas available and should get Beams back next week. Jolly and Young sustained injuries at the weekend but both don't look too severe.

SUPERCOACH WATCH: Sam Dwyer is tipped to rise $81,000 next week and looks safe – for now – in Collingwood's side. He costs only $96,200 and is dual-position.

Dale Thomas tries to get around Chris Giampaolo during the VFL match between Collingwood and North Ballarat at Victoria Park Picture: Harman Stephen Source: Herald Sun

Live HQ: SuperCoach scores, stats and more from every Round 2 match

CARLTON

INJURIES
Eddie Betts (jaw) 3 weeks
Shaun Hampson (appendicitis) 1 week
Patrick McCarthy (heel) test
Andrew Collins (ankle) 1 week
David Ellard (hamstring) 1 week
Jarrad Waite (calf) 1-2 weeks
Rhys O'Keeffe (foot) 2 weeks
Nick Graham (knee) 7 weeks
Andrew McInnes (knee) 10 weeks

ON THE BLOCK: Youngster Josh Bootsma had his colours lowered against Jamie Elliott (five goals). Levi Casboult and Sam Rowe will be looking over their shoulders as Shaun Hampson pushes for selection.

ON THE CUSP: Heath Scotland will be a walk-up start for the Blues and a welcome inclusion down back after serving his two-match club suspension. Robbie Warnock starred in the ruck for the Northern Blues along with Ed Curnow (30 disposals) and Dylan Buckley.

GILBERT GARDINER'S FORECAST: When master coach Mick Malthouse signed with Carlton, some at Visy Park and nearby Lygon St for that matter had September glory on their minds. Wonder what they're thinking now with the Blues staring down the barrel of a 0-3 start under the triple premiership coach. Geelong will punish the Blues unless they can find consistent avenues to goal. It worked yesterday with small-to-medium sized forwards lighting up the MCG. Casboult and Rowe (one goal) provided strong targets but failed to impact the scoreboard. This game is huge as the Blues travel west next week.

ESSENDON

INJURIES
Stewie Crameri (knee) TBC

ON THE BLOCK: No block at Bomberland with the Dons on top of the table and facing a showdown with the undefeated Dockers on Friday night. Crameri's knee must come up this week, while Nick Kommer is on the edge after starting as the sub and with a host of VFL players pressing. But even Kommer would be stiff after gathering nine disposals at 89 per cent efficiency in a quarter.

ON THE CUSP: Everyone. The Dons launched their stand-alone VFL side with a 90-point win on Friday night with Jason Winderlich booting eight goals in three quarters. By his own admission, Winderlich needs more game time at second-tier level, but Leroy Jetta thrust his hand up with 34 possessions in the midfield. Joe Daniher booted five while Tayte Pears applied pressure on the Dons' defence with a stellar performance at half-back. All smiles at Windy Hill.

SAM LANDSBERGER'S FORECAST: The Dons got the job done against Fremantle in Perth last year, albeit before both club's seasons spiralled in opposite directions. They enter with a clean bill of health, a dozen players pressing for promotion and full of form. Expect little change again ahead of the Friday night blockbuster.

SUPERCOACH WATCH: David Zahrakis has worn both the green and red vests in the first two weeks. That should translate to a price drop and he could be a bargain in about a month.

GALLERY: See the best 40 photos from Round 2

FREMANTLE

INJURIES
Zac Clarke (achilles) test
Anthony Morabito (knee) indefinite
Aaron Sandilands (hamstring) 8 weeks
Jesse Crichton (quadriceps) 1-2 weeks
Clancee Pearce (corkie) test

ON THE BLOCK: Clancee Pearce was substituted out of the match with a corkie but should keep his spot. No major injuries to come out of last Saturday's win against the Western Bulldogs.

ON THE CUSP: Alex Silvagni was the pick of the Dockers-listed players in the WAFL with 22 disposals and four marks.

GILBERT GARDINER'S FORECAST: It's all systems go for the Dockers who will be looking for 3-0 launching pad into the season against Essendon on Friday night. Nat Fyfe is working up through his gears and Jon Griffin has stood up to replace Sandilands. Michael Walters has improved sharply with another Lyon pre-season under his belt. The small forward has kicked two bags of three against West Coast and the Western Bulldogs. Expect Bombers tagger Heath Hocking to get the job on Michael Barlow.

GEELONG

INJURIES
Daniel Menzel (knee) test
Jared Rivers (knee) test
Jordan Murdoch (hand) test
Steve Johnson (knee) 1-2 weeks
Josh Cowan (Achilles) indefinite
Hamish McIntosh (knee) indefinite
George Burbury (foot) indefinite
Jed Bews (foot) indefinite
Josh Hunt (glandular fever) indefinite
Dawson Simpson (back) Indefinite

ON THE BLOCK: Mitch Brown was subbed out and could make way if Jared Rivers returns this week. Other than that it's hard to see the Cats making too many changes ahead of their clash against the Blues.

ON THE CUSP: The Cats' VFL side had a bye at the weekend, but impressed last week. George Horlin-Smith and Jesse Stringer are close to selection. Daniel Menzel should return through the VFL this week.

SAM LANDSBERGER'S FORECAST: Jimmy Bartel continued the Cats' perfect start to the season with this match-winning goal and expect little change to the winning formula. Another six-day break means Chris Scott might juggle a few names around to keep his side fresh, particularly with another short turnaround to follow ahead of Round 4. And keep an eye on first-round pick Jackson Thurlow. The man in Corey Enright's mould is edging towards an AFL debut.

Jimmy Bartel kicks the winning goal for Geelong. Picture: George Salpigtidis Source: Herald Sun

GOLD COAST

INJURIES
Greg Broughton (calf) TBC
Liam Patrick (hamstring) 1 week
Jacob Gilbee (suspension) 2 weeks
Seb Tape (knee) 2 weeks
Jesse Lonergan (wrist) 3 weeks
Campbell Brown (suspension) 4 weeks
Nathan Bock (leg) indefinite

ON THE BLOCK: Not too many after a Round 1 win and impressive fight for three quarters against the premiers. Zac Smith was beaten in the ruck, while Luke Russell was quiet and only tracked at 40 per cent efficiency.

ON THE CUSP: Ruckman Daniel Gorringe returned in the reserves and booted a goal. Clay Cameron was best-afield and is edging towards a debut, while Danny Stanley also put himself in the mix. Tom Lynch returned but might need one more week in the NEAFL for match conditioning.

SAM LANDSBERGER'S FORECAST: A first-up win followed by a competitive loss sets up a crunch Q-Clash against the winless Lions. And it's at Metricon – a ground the Suns suddenly know how to win at after victories against the Saints and Blues there. After that it's Port Adelaide at home and the Giants. Could the Suns be in the eight after Round 5?

SUPERCOACH WATCH: After a unique pick in the backline? Sun Charlie Dixon costs under $400k and has opened the year with scores of 130 and 123.

GWS

INJURIES
Taylor Adams (hip) TBC
Matthew Buntine (lung) 4 weeks
Dom Tyson (knee) 6 weeks
Chad Cornes (shoulder) Indefinite

ON THE BLOCK: The Giants burst out of the blocks but couldn't maintain the rage against the Power. Will Hoskin-Elliott started as the sub, which is never a good sign, while Curtly Hampton was quiet. Adam Kennedy and Rhys Palmer had 10 touches each and Kevin Sheedy doesn't mind rotating his side heavily.

ON THE CUSP: Plenty. Setant O'hAilpin booted three goals in the reserves, Anthony Miles was best-afield and No.2 draft pick Jono O'Rourke made a low-key return from a hamstring injury. He's a devastating midfielder who will add another dimension to this slick engine room sooner rather than later.

SAM LANDSBERGER'S FORECAST: The Giants' injury list is thinning nicely and, coupled with their improved efforts, makes the new side a touch more unpredictable. The Saints, Dees and Suns in the next three weeks should translate to at least one victory. And with Lachie Whitfield and Stephen Coniglio joining Dylan Shiel, Adam Treloar and Cal Ward as midfielders able to swing matches, the future is starting to look extremely scary.

HAWTHORN

INJURIES
Xavier Ellis (calf) 2 weeks
Matthew Suckling (knee) indefinite
Brendan Whitecross (knee) 6 weeks
Alex Woodward (knee) indefinite

ON THE BLOCK: A stellar win in the west but expect a couple of changes as Alastair Clarkson freshens up his side for the Collingwood blockbuster. Jed Anderson was lively but could fall out of the side, while Shane Savage earned a late reprieve but was handed vest duties, making him vulnerable. Brad Sewell was subbed out with suspected hamstring tightness and will be monitored this week.

ON THE CUSP: Hawthorn's recycled talent is barging the door down. Brian Lake could bolster the back half after getting through his VFL return yesterday unscathed. He racked up 13 disposals, while former Cat Jon Simpkin was prolific with 31 disposals and is right on the verge of his Hawks debut. Matt Spangher also impressed, while ex-Dee Kyle Cheney had 20 touches and was named Box Hill's best. Jack Gunston is also available after making way at the last minute against West Coast.

SAM LANDSBERGER'S FORECAST: Hawthorn's nightmare scenario – a 0-2 start ahead of the Collingwood showdown – has been avoided after collecting the points in fine fashion in the west yesterday. That brings some relief, and with Hodge back and Brian Lake to follow things are looking up for Clarkson's side. Expect Simpkin – a dual Cats VFL best-and-fairest winner – to come in this week.

Hawthorn defender Brian Lake is no certainty to line up against West Coast on Sunday. Picture: Harman Stephen Source: Herald Sun

MELBOURNE

INJURIES
Jordie McKenzie (calf) TBC
Jack Fitzpatrick (concussion) test
Lynden Dunn (hamstring tightness) 1 week
Nathan Stark (knee) 1 week
Joel Macdonald (hamstring) 2 weeks
Chris Dawes (hamstring) 3 weeks

ON THE BLOCK: More like who isn't on the block? Just four Dees gathered more than 14 disposals. Ouch. The pressure will build on No.1 pick Jack Watts to retain his place this week, while Sam Blease, Colin Sylvia and David Rodan are all right on the edge. Does Mark Neeld keep swinging the axe or stick fat with his 22?

ON THE CUSP: At least the Dees playing for Casey yesterday showed some heart. Dean Kent was exceptional with his pace and must be close to an AFL debut. The 19-year-old kicked an amazing running goal after four bounces, while Luke Tapscott looks certain to return after booting 6.2 – including five in the first half – from 23 disposals. Rohan Bail is also ready to return, while Max Gawn dominated with two goals from 20 hitouts and he showed a bit of mongrel.

SAM LANDSBERGER'S FORECAST: Rightly or wrongly, it seems all the outside attention will focus on the Round 4 clash against GWS instead of Saturday's duel with West Coast. The pressure is mounting, but at least the Dees' injury list isn't too bad and there are players at Casey putting their hands up.

Demons v Bombers, MCG, Jack Watts, Picture: Ludbey Wayne Source: HWT Image Library

NORTH MELBOURNE

INJURIES
Nil

ON THE BLOCK: It was a tough day at the office for highly-rated youngster Kieran Harper, subbed off during the third quarter with just six disposals to his name. Harper also had three clangers which won't help his cause. Lachie Hansen failed to fire a shot, registering seven disposals and three marks.

ON THE CUSP: Brad McKenzie could push for selection after beating Magpie veteran Alan Didak in a head-to-head VFL battle at the weekend. The 2011 No.18 pick collected 27 disposals at 93 per cent efficiency playing for North Ballarat. Didak picked up 22 touches. Majak Daw booted two goals for Werribee. Meanwhile, Bees ruckman Daniel Currie struggled to make an impact after dislocating a finger in the first quarter against the Northern Blues.

GILBERT GARDINER'S FORECAST: North would be filthy after dropping two winnable games thus far. The Swans pose more problems for the Brad Scott's men who must find a way to play four solid quarters of football. Aaron Mullett has been a revelation off half-back while Lindsay Thomas' mojo is well and truly back. Todd Goldstein did a power of work last week and must repeat the dose against in-form Swans combination Mike Pyke and Shane Mumford.

PORT ADELAIDE

INJURIES
Brett Ebert (adductor) test
Hamish Hartlett (back) available
Jay Schulz (ankle) available

ON THE BLOCK: Power coach Ken Hinkley expects both Hartlett and Schulz, subbed out with an ankle injury, to be right for the Showdown. Kane Mitchell is vulnerable having started as the substitute the past couple of weeks.

ON THE CUSP: John Butcher (five goals) must come into consideration for Sunday's grudge match against cross-town rivals Adelaide. Andrew Moore showed promise with 22 touches including eight clearances for North Adelaide.

GILBERT GARDINER FORECAST: All going well at Alberton under rookie coach Hinkley. The midfield is working a treat with Boak, Hartlett and Cornes showing positive signs. Expect Ollie Wines to bounce back after a quiet week. Port will be looking to turn the tables after losing the past three Showdowns. Schulz is central to the Power's chances of success and a 3-0 dream start to the season.

RICHMOND

INJURIES
Nathan Foley (Achilles) 4-6 weeks
David Astbury (foot) 1-2 weeks

ON THE BLOCK: Brandon Ellis could be in trouble after being subbed off in Round 1 and starting in the subs vest on Friday night, although he had an impact when he came on late. Hard to find another player who deserves to be dropped on form but team balance might be an issue – do the Tigers need so many tall and medium defenders against the Bulldogs?

ON THE CUSP: Former Crow Chris Knights put a battering ram through Damien Hardwick's proverbial selection door when he picked up 41 disposals in Coburg's big win against Sandringham yesterday. Knights, who was picked up as a free agent at the end of last season, also registered eight clearances, eight inside-50s and a goal and could be the mid-sized forward the Tigers need. Others to impress in the VFL included Aaron Edwards (four goals and 17 disposals), Brad Helbig (26 touches) and Robin Nahas (22 and six tackles). Nick Vlastuin (16 disposals) might have to wait another week.

AL PATON'S FORECAST: The last time Richmond won the first three matches of a season was in 1995, when the Tigers went on to win the first eight and make a preliminary final. We don't want to get ahead of ourselves but momentum is building at Punt Rd and depth is no longer a problem. They should have the Dogs covered, then comes a serious test with matches against Collingwood, Fremantle (in Perth) and Geelong.

ST KILDA

INJURIES
Daniel Markworth (knee) season
Sean Dempster (hand) 3 weeks
James Gwilt (knee) 3-5 weeks
Farren Ray (hip) 1-2 weeks
Tom Hickey (foot) 1 week
Jackson Ferguson (knee) 4 weeks

ON THE BLOCK: Dempster is a big loss to an already depleted backline. Arryn Siposs was subbed out on Friday night with just nine disposals but he'll be given more chances. Scott Watters says Stephen Milne won't be dropped but he would be keen for a big game. So far in 2013 he has kicked 2.4 – and registered just one tackle. The Saints' other small forwards flashed in and out of the game against Richmond and all had their moments, but how many do they need? Probably a question for the list manager.

ON THE CUSP: Worryingly, the most eye-catching performance in the VFL came from yet another small forward, with Trent Dennis-Lane kicking five goals. Top draft pick Nathan Wright was impressive at half-back and could make his debut as Dempster's replacement, with Tom Simpkin another option. Justin Koschitzke kicked two goals as did mature-age recruit Tom Lee, but neither was listed in the best players.

AL PATON'S FORECAST: The Saints were in the game for the full 120 minutes against Richmond but could never quite bridge the gap the Tigers established early. They should register their first win of the season against GWS in Canberra on Saturday, although it's unlikely to be as easy as the 128-point romp the last time the two teams played. After that life doesn't get any easier with assignments against Essendon, Sydney, Collingwood and Carlton. Some good news from Friday night was Sam Fisher and Adam Schneider got through unscathed in their returns from injury – Schneider had a big influence after being subbed on – and both should be a lot better this week.

SYDNEY

INJURIES
Alex Johnson (knee) indefinite
Gary Rohan (leg) indefinite

ON THE BLOCK: Substitute Craig Bird made the most of his time on the ground picking up seven disposals – four contested – in the final quarter.

ON THE CUSP: Mitch Morton was solid last time out with three goals in the reserves while Dean Rampe could return after being omitted last week.

GILBERT GARDINER'S FORECAST: No risks for the Swans as it's all about getting through each match with the four premiership points and no injuries. After comfortably accounting for GWS and Gold Coast, the Swans can expect a tougher task against a North Melbourne outfit stung by two close losses. But the Bloods boast an imposing record over their rivals, having defeated the Kangaroos the past six times. Jarrad McVeigh is off to a flyer while Luke Parker is finally stepping into Jude Bolton's shoes. Watch for Adam Goodes to step up after a slow start to his 15th season.

WEST COAST

INJURIES
Daniel Kerr (knee) test
Eric Mackenzie (hamstring) test
Patrick McGinnity (back) test
Mark LeCras (arm) test
Nic Naitanui (groin) 2 weeks
Matt Rosa (quad) 3 weeks
Sharrod Wellingham (ankle) 4 weeks
Mark Nicoski (hamstring) 6-8 weeks

ON THE BLOCK: Small forward Ashton Hams could find himself back in the WAFL after picking up just two disposals in three quarters. Substitute Bradd Dalziell provided a bit of dash when activated while former Saint Jamie Cripps (eight disposals, three clangers) put in a below-par effort.

ON THE CUSP: Eagles star Daniel Kerr collected 23 disposals including three inside-50s for East Fremantle and should make the trip to Melbourne. Remarkably, Mark LeCras is also a chance to play just two weeks after breaking his arm in the opening round. But Eric Mackenzie is likely to miss another week with a tight hamstring. Small forward Murray Newman was handy in his state league match, picking up 15 disposals and five marks including seven inside-50s.

GILBERT GARDINER'S FORECAST: It's getting serious now for the Eagles who have been hamstrung with injuries to key players. But Saturday's task against Melbourne should be a no-brainer. The Eagles need Kerr back to relieve the pressure on Matthew Priddis around the stoppages. But match fitness – or lack of – could decide his fate. The substitute's vest might be the answer. Spearhead Josh Kennedy kicked five in three quarters against the Hawks. How many can he pile on against Melbourne?

WESTERN BULLDOGS

INJURIES
Easton Wood (hamstring) available
Dylan Addison (hamstring) test
Tom Williams (foot) test
Matthew Boyd (calf) 1 week
Nathan Hrovat (calf) 1-2 weeks

ON THE BLOCK: The Dogs lost to the Dockers but showed fight to the end, meaning little change can again be expected. Ayce Cordy was quiet but is developing nicely and should be safe, while small forwards Shaun Higgins, Daniel Giansiracusa and Tory Dickson were well held. But after their Round 1 heroics – and invaluable experience and class – they've got nothing to fear.

ON THE CUSP: Affiliate Williamstown had the bye at the weekend, but several Dogs got minutes in the legs in the VFL reserves on Saturday. Of those pressing for selection, prized draft picks Jake Stringer and Jackson Macrae are at the top of the list. Stringer's mature body has him primed for an early-season debut, while Macrae's scintillating second half for the Seagulls last week was full of tricks that elevated him to the 25-man squad against Fremantle.

SAM LANDSBERGER'S FORECAST: The Dogs beat Fremantle in disposals, contested possessions and conceded just one fewer inside-50 against the Dockers and were made to pay for their slow start out of the blocks. They now prepare for the undefeated Tigers in Daniel Cross's 200th match. Expect Nick Lower to tag Trent Cotchin, but there is likely to be little change at the selection table, save for Easton Wood's likely inclusion.

SUPERCOACH WATCH: Tom Liberatore's contested style has been heavily rewarded in the first two weeks. He scored 133 on Saturday and you can grab him this week before a projected price rise of about $50,000.

Welcome to the major league, lads: Jake Stringer and Jackson Macrae after being selected at No.5 and No.6 by the Western Bulldogs. Picture: Wayne Ludbey Source: Herald Sun

AFL OFFICIALS

INJURIES
Courtney Lai (knee) season

Goal umpire Lai ruptured his ACL and PCL in this collision with Bulldog Liam Picken on Saturday. He'll have surgery on Thursday.
 

16.55 | 0 komentar | Read More

LeCras could face the Dees

Eagle Mark LeCras comes off the ground with a serious arm injury. Picture: Daniel Wilkins Source: PerthNow

STAR West Coast forward could make a shock return against Melbourne on Saturday, just three weeks after breaking his arm.

LeCras is listed as a "test" on the Eagles' injury list and could join West Coast's travelling party to Melbourne on Thursday.

The West Coast website has reported that If the mercurial goalkicker trains without discomfort this week he is poised to play, in another blow to the Demons and coach Mark Neeld's embarrassing start to the season.

LeCras underwent surgery following his injury and had a plate inserted into his arm. He was on fire in the Round 1 derby before colliding with Docker Tendai Mzungu.

The Eagles could also welcome back Daniel Kerr for the MCG clash after he gathered 23 disposals in the WAFL on Saturday.

Get a full injury update at The Barometer

16.55 | 0 komentar | Read More

Bartel, Cats deny Roos

A controversial free kick and 50m penalty has gifted Geelong another remarkable comeback victory at Etihad Stadium today.

Geelong v North Melbourne at Etihad Stadium, Docklands. Jimmy Bartel kicks the winning goal Picture: Salpigtidis George Source: Herald Sun

Geelong star Jimmy Bartel works his way through traffic against North Melbourne. Picture: Salpigtidis George Source: Herald Sun

SELF-BELIEF was Geelong's trademark in three premiership triumphs and continues to deliver the Cats stunning results.

That never-quit work ethic allowed Geelong to steal a four-point win against North Melbourne at Etihad Stadium yesterday.

In a remarkable turnaround, the Cats whittled away a deficit that ballooned to 41 points late in the second quarter to hit the front for the second time with only 20 seconds left in the game.

"We weren't really testing them. We just had to try to play our way and see how they handled that," experienced defender Andrew Mackie said.

Live HQ: SuperCoach scores, stats

"To the boys' credit, we got on top in the middle and that makes a difference, a bit like last week (against Hawthorn)."

In a gripping final term, the Kangaroos lost the lead and then regained it with a goal from Daniel Wells after Mitch Duncan conceded a 50m penalty.

Ironically, it was another 50m penalty that allowed Cat Jimmy Bartel to kick the sealing goal inside the last minute after Nathan Grima fell into his back and then Michael Firrito roosted the ball away.

What would have been a pressure shot for Bartel from 40m became a gift from the goalline. The Cats created two stoppages after the restart to run down the clock.

Geelong v North Melbourne at Etihad Stadium, Docklands. Harry Taylor , Trent West and Josh Caddy celebrate on the final siren Picture: Salpigtidis George Source: Herald Sun

Another second-half revival left Geelong coach Chris Scott with mixed emotions - while he marvelled at the resilience of his players he was determined to dissect a lacklustre first half.

"I'm exhausted without having to run a metre. It was difficult to watch in the first half and that's what we're going to focus on," he said.

"The things that we went in planning to do weren't implemented and they were a different team than the one that played Round 1. Due credit to their skills and decision-making, but those options shouldn't have been available.

"A lot of the questioning today will be around the competitiveness of our players, their discipline to get back to what we wanted to do pre-game and really fight their way back.

"But we don't accept that, it's not good enough to rely on efforts like that to get back into games of footy because our first half was poor."

North monopolised the ball in the first half, working harder and hitting their targets to rack up nearly double the Cats' possessions.

Geelong v North Melbourne at Etihad Stadium, Docklands. Nathan Grima after the loss Picture: Salpigtidis George Source: Herald Sun

That control and accuracy inside the forward 50 wasn't reflected on the scoreboard with only a 19-point lead at quarter-time to show for the Roos toil. But it had stretched to 35 at halftime.

Geelong will reflect on two telling moves that fuelled the momentum switch in the second half.

 Almost as telling as Mathew Stokes super-sub performance was defender Harry Taylor's shutdown of dangerous Kangaroo tall target Drew Petrie.

Taylor went back on to Petrie after the big Roo had booted his fourth goal on Tom Lonergan early in the second term and he didn't add to the tally.

It was another example that the game doesn't allow anyone to bathe in glory for long ... Lonergan, who contained Lance Franklin only six days earlier, had his second opponent and four goals against him after just over a quarter.

Like the opening round against Hawthorn, the Cats' daring and run created overlaps and the willingness to risk another handball applied enormous pressure to the Roos defence after halftime.

"We have confidence that we can score quickly, but in my time at Geelong it appears no player ever gives up and that's a really admirable trait," Scott said.

"We're really proud of our guys, but I guess we can't just rely on that experience to get us back into the game when it's slipping away from us. I guess it's slightly intimidating for opposition teams when they know they're playing a team that never gives up. But we have to focus on not putting ourselves in that position in the first place."

Geelong v North Melbourne at Etihad Stadium, Docklands. Brad Scott talking with the AFL's ( Graham Finn ? ) ground manger after the loss about the roof policy after the loss. Picture: Salpigtidis George Source: Herald Sun

16.55 | 0 komentar | Read More

Magpies down Mick's Blues

Collingwood forward Jamie Elliott booted five goals to steer the Magpies to victory. Picture: Ludbey Wayne Source: Herald Sun

A SPIRITED Collingwood have overcome injury for the second straight round to notch a thrilling comeback AFL win over Carlton and keep former Magpies coach Mick Malthouse winless at his new club.

Small forward Jamie Elliott kicked five goals, including two in the last term, as the Magpies stormed back from 10 points down at the last change to win 17.15 (117) to 15.10 (100) in front of a crowd of 84,247.

As well as his own contribution on the scoreboard, Elliott dished a handball to Steele Sidebottom that set up the sealer with less than a minute to play, with Scott Pendlebury ramming home another major in the final seconds.

The Magpies had seemed in big trouble early, when Carlton's Andrew Walker kicked the first three goals of the match and Collingwood ruckman Darren Jolly went down with a rib injury in the opening minutes.

Live HQ: SuperCoach scores, stats

Jolly returned briefly to the field at the start of the second quarter but was soon subbed out, meaning key forward recruit Quinten Lynch had to spend most of the day in the ruck.

He was thrashed in the hit-outs by Carlton's Matthew Kreuzer but worked valiantly at ground level, picking up 24 disposals and six clearances.

It also meant Travis Cloke, who was kept goal-less by Michael Jamison, had to play largely a lone hand as a marking target in attack.

But with Cloke failing to fire, Elliott stepped into the breach beautifully while small midfielder Jarryd Blair also chipped in with two goals.

As in last year's two clashes between these two sides, Carlton's small forwards were very dangerous and looked set to prove match-winners, with Chris Yarran and Jeff Garlett kicking three goals each.

Together with Walker's early haul and strong midfield showings by Marc Murphy and Chris Judd, it was enough to help Carlton lead for most of the day.

But goals to Magpies Ben Sinclair, Elliott and Blair in the first eight minutes of the last term gave Collingwood a 10-point lead.

And despite Garlett responding with a sensational snap from outside 50m to narrow the gap to less than a kick, they never gave up the lead.

Heath Shaw, Dane Swan, Sidebottom, Pendlebury and recruit Sam Dwyer were all important midfield contributors for the Magpies.

16.55 | 0 komentar | Read More